• The new WDWMAGIC iOS app is here!
    Stay up to date with the latest Disney news, photos, and discussions right from your iPhone. The app is free to download and gives you quick access to news articles, forums, photo galleries, park hours, weather and Lightning Lane pricing. Learn More
  • Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
    Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.

Rank the 10 American Disney/Universal Parks

Which is the BEST park?


  • Total voters
    49

DLR92

Well-Known Member
No interest to see the parks in Florida? As much as I prefer Disneyland to just about all other parks, I still find this sad. I know that this thread is about the parks, specially... but, IMO, the best aspect of the Florida parks is taking all the forms of transportation and visiting all the areas in-between, including the resorts. That goes for both Disney and Universal. Both have boats to get to some of the resorts. Taking the WDW monorail to the Contemporary, the Polynesian, and the Grand Foridian is not to be missed, although the Poly Lobby is not what it was before 2015, sadly. I usually spend my first day in town wandering around those really cool nooks and crannies.

I have feelings about what's become of FL since the good old days, and the remnants of "Old Florida", but being in those park bubbles is pretty fantastic, as long as you're not planning on going the during summer heat.

Likewise, it seems like most of the people that I've met on the east coast have no interest in Disneyland, and also have no actual concept of how it's really any different than Magic Kingdom, other than it just being smaller. For this reason, I'm actually happy that MK is going through a metamorphosis, so that these parks can be even more different. Maybe this will encourage more travel between coasts, politics not withstanding.

I also personally love traveling, but I do know that not everyone has the means or desire to do so. My wife and I went to Paris last October, and started the trip off at DLP. I'm glad that we did that, even if that park wouldn't necessarily go between my top 3-5 parks in the US.
Do I want to spend $$$$$ for the same product in California for less? I wouldn’t have to spend air fare, hotels, car rental just for a Disney vacation in Florida. I rather be sight seeing other world class cities in foreign countries with spending $$$$$.
I have the real deal with Hotel Del Coronado in San Diego with a real beach.

I would rather see international Disney parks than set foot in Florida. But I’m not spending a week exclusively at the international Disney parks. Thats absurd to miss out on authentic cultural differences.
 
Last edited:

GordoInTheParks

Active Member
Do I want to spend $$$$$ for the same product in California for less? I wouldn’t have to spend air fare, hotels, car rental just for a Disney vacation in Florida. I rather be sight seeing other world class cities in foreign countries with spending $$$$$.
I have the real deal with Hotel Del Coronado in San Diego with a real beach.

I would rather see international Disney parks than set foot in Florida. But I’m not spending a week exclusively at the international Disney parks. Thats absurd to miss out on authentic cultural differences.

Firstly, I love San Diego, and my wife and I had a great time touring the historic Hotel Del Coronado grounds, when we visited there a couple years back! We didn't end up staying there, but we really like to stay at a lot of historic hotels, especially here in Colorado.

Still, I know WDW is a very expensive proposition, and I also know that I'm probably not making a dent in conveying how completely different the overall experience of Disney parks is when staying somewhere on Disney property in FL, and taking their forms of transportation, like the Skyliner and monorail around. You don't really need a rental car, but it can make things easier, especially since I don't like the busses as much. But even some of their budget hotels are pretty close to the Skyliner. There's also the Animal Kingdom Lodge, which is honestly one of the most beautiful places I've ever stayed at. However, you can just visit and see the animals in the Savanna. The pictures don't really do it justice.. m Yes, the San Diego Zoo is absolutely stunning, but Animal Kingdom and both lodges are all such an amazing sight, as well.

1000018150.jpg

1000018151.jpg

I know that the giraffes and other animals are out of sight in the 2nd photo, but I just can't get over the fact that this is outside the hotel rooms or the lobby patio viewing area.

BTW, I would never advise anyone to ever stay at an international park for a week, and not see anything else, nor would I ever do that. I said that I spent my first 1.5 days around DLP, with 1 park day out of the 10 days that I spent in Paris, total. We got a lot in around Paris, and did waking tours, boat tours, many museums, cafés, bistros, patisseries, etc. We made that choice based on "when else would we be able to do this?" and stuck to it!

We are far from wealthy, but we do fly on points most of the time, and we also are clever at booking pricing, as well as save up for all of our trips, as having memorable experiences is just our priority in life, which is WAY TOO SHORT!

Edit: sorry for the double post!
 
Last edited:

Pizza Moon

Well-Known Member
AK is sort of my favorite but it just doesn’t hold you, so I can’t wait for Tropical Americas more than any of these new lands.

I’d say:

1. Disneyland Park
2. Universal Epic Universe
3. Islands of Adventure
4. Magic Kingdom
5. Disney California Adventure
6. Disney’s Animal Kingdom
7. EPCOT
8. Disney’s Hollywood Studios
9. Universal Studios Hollywood
10. Universal Studios Florida

For parks I’ve been to:
  1. Tokyo DisneySea
  2. Disneyland Park
  3. Epic Universe
  4. Islands of Adventure
  5. Europa Park
  6. Shanghai Disneyland
  7. Tokyo Disneyland
  8. Magic Kingdom
  9. Disneyland Paris
  10. Disney California Adventure
  11. EPCOT
  12. Disney’s Animal Kingdom
  13. Disney’s Hollywood Studios
  14. Universal Studios Hollywood
  15. Hong Kong Disneyland
  16. Universal Studios Florida
  17. Disney Adventure World (when it was WDSP)
 

PiratesMansion

Well-Known Member
With the asterisk that I haven't been to many of the Floridian parks in many years:

1. Disneyland
2. Islands of Adventure
3. DAK (unpopular take, I know)
4. Epcot
5. USH (the studio tour, Waterworld, and the overall vibe of the park is doing a lot of work here)
6. Magic Kingdom (honestly my least favorite castle park; shout-out to their Space Mountain for uniqueness and ejector airtime in the dark)
7. DHS (love the OG Tower of Terror though!)
8. DCA (Meh)
9. USF (could easily swap with DCA; right now, DCA is winning simply because at least more attractions still exist in a way that is compromised rather than being straight-up removed; still love Men in Black, though.)

Haven't been to Epic, but I'm sure it would beat several of these parks.
 

PiratesMansion

Well-Known Member
Do I want to spend $$$$$ for the same product in California for less? I wouldn’t have to spend air fare, hotels, car rental just for a Disney vacation in Florida. I rather be sight seeing other world class cities in foreign countries with spending $$$$$.
I have the real deal with Hotel Del Coronado in San Diego with a real beach.

I would rather see international Disney parks than set foot in Florida. But I’m not spending a week exclusively at the international Disney parks. Thats absurd to miss out on authentic cultural differences.
To be fair, it's not the same product; it's a very different product with VERY different strengths.

What makes WDW special and unique is all the stuff you can't do anywhere else; Epcot, DAK (even though yes, it does pull pretty obviously from San Diego in spots), the mini golf (or regular golf, if you prefer), the water parks, the best shopping and dining district of any of the parks, beautiful hotels that are fun to explore, the plethora of unique, beautifully themed table service restaurants, and so on.

You just can't treat it like you treat Disneyland, because that tends to immediately throw the resort's flaws immediately into stark relief. Now, part of that is on WDW for not doing a better job on some things DLR simply executes better, but part of that is DLR vets simply being unwilling to meet WDW on its own terms. In California, Disneyland is the special place and everything else is basically add-ons of varying levels of quality and acceptance within the DLR fan community. In Florida, the add-ons are the point, and the way it all can be infinitely customizable to fit any scenario makes it all VERY repeatable to some people who frequent it. Additionally, the locals in Florida don't hang out in Magic Kingdom or regard that as the best place to be most of the time-that is decidedly tilted in favor of Epcot. Whereas a lot of California locals go right to Magic Kingdom when they visit WDW because to them, a Disney Theme Park often *can only be* something like Disneyland (DCA sure isn't cutting it, you know? And so the narrative becomes entrenched that there is One Correct Way to do a Disney Theme Park, even if subconsciously, for many people, IME) and discover, sure enough, the entire internet was right and Magic Kingdom is, indeed, a worse Disneyland. So some people are setting themselves up for a self-fulfilling prophecy and then screaming about their own failure to the internet, or so it seems to me.

I understand the notion of not wanting to do what you have at home, what might be inferior, etc., but I also passionately and sincerely advocate that if you love any one of these places, you owe it to yourself to try and see them all. The international parks in particular can often be done relatively quickly and cheaply. I find the differences interesting rather than being a deal breaker.

But it does take the right mindset. You have to be willing to go in and accept that things are done differently, and that the way one property operates is just that. Different is not necessarily bad. There is, of course, the opportunity cost. Visiting Disney elsewhere is likely to be expensive and come at the expense of something else that might be more personally interesting, and I can't fault people for being unwilling to give that up. But frankly, I think the parks fandom would be a better place in many ways if more people were willing and able to sample the other parks with an open mind, in addition to whichever one they happen to frequent.
 
Last edited:

mickEblu

Well-Known Member
The international parks in particular can often be done relatively quickly and cheaply.

Thats sure what it seems like. Looks like Fall 2027 is when things are finally going to line up for us to go to WDW and yet when push comes to shove and the time comes when realize you are about to pay 10k+ of real money to go to Orlando (when you've already been to Florida 3 times) you cant help but think hmmm maybe if I need to start this Disney Park Tour so bad Paris or Tokyo is way to go? Both of those cities/ countries are high on my list anyway. Granted it's a different kind of trip and instead of being at the parks for 6-7 days or so you are there for 3 but you get to enjoy new cultures, try new food, see a different part of the world including perhaps some of the nearby cities/ countries. For someone that hasn't done a whole of international travel it kind of sounds like the move. Of course the logistics and travel aren't as kid friendly and you only get to knock out two parks instead of 4. Who knows, maybe if I end up meeting my cousin at Shanghai DL for a quick solo trip next March I'll have a change of heart. The weather in March in Shanghai doesn't look that great though.
 

BrianLo

Well-Known Member
Right I guess my question is if one had never been to Disneyland would MK still rank behind Epcot and AK? For some maybe, for others no. I’m sure it depends on many factors and who’s evaluating.

With/for the kids? Probably not.

I’m a Florida original and my parents (and maybe me?) did prefer Epcot, but that’s the early 90’s Epcot and there was a clear retrenchment.
 

BrianLo

Well-Known Member
  1. Disneyland
  2. (1.5)Tokyo Disney Sea
  3. Tokyo Disneyland
  4. Magic Kingdom
  5. Disneyland Paris
  6. Epcot
  7. Efteling
  8. Shanghai Disneyland
  9. DAK
  10. Hong Kong Disneyland
  11. Epic—
  12. USJ
  13. DCA
  14. DHS
  15. IOA
  16. ?DAW
  17. USH
  18. USF—
  19. Universal Singapore
  20. ?USB
  21. WDSP
Have this saved on a long running phone notepad. DAW is sort of a guess based on current metrics.

Over the years I think the biggest surprising mover and shaker is that IOA has fallen maybe 10 places. In its current form I must say I spent more time at USF and I don’t even really like USF. IOA when you stop to consider it is nothing more than a daisy chain of aging E tickets, a horrible park navigational layout, a bunch of water rides you don’t really feel like having soggy socks for, a surprising amount of closed off attractions spaces, absolute zero entertainment, not great food since Disney and Epic have largely improved and Potter/Jurassic Park.

USSingapore is the line where I feel like the parks are actually starting to get bad and I would actively not recommend people try to seek them/visit them purposefully. USF floats just above there and has its moments.

Everything epic and above I’d call quite good parks (not critiscm free). Below Epic I have some moderate to progressively major notes.
 
Last edited:

Pizza Moon

Well-Known Member
Do I want to spend $$$$$ for the same product in California for less? I wouldn’t have to spend air fare, hotels, car rental just for a Disney vacation in Florida. I rather be sight seeing other world class cities in foreign countries with spending $$$$$.
I have the real deal with Hotel Del Coronado in San Diego with a real beach.

I would rather see international Disney parks than set foot in Florida. But I’m not spending a week exclusively at the international Disney parks. Thats absurd to miss out on authentic cultural differences.
Disneyland Park > MK and it’s not close, like not even close. For like a quick 2-day trip, Disneyland takes the cake and then some in my opinion.

On top of it Disneyland Resort as a whole lets you have midnight park hours, and walking distance hotels the price of Walt Disney World value hotels, and a vibe that’s less touristy.

It’s lovely.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom