I never said the aesthetic of an old, dated mall led to them falling out of fashion, simply that theming an optimistic future to look like an old outdated currently existing aesthetic might not be the best way to go with theme.
Malls that looked like that were already feeling like a remnant of the 70's and 80's. Then to go to Disneyland and see their world of the future look like that same thing....It would be like designing a Tomorrowland that looks like an old Apple Store. It may have been an optimistic and original take in its day, but now it is way too familiar and reminds us of dying aspect of our civilization.
Rockwork, masonry, sculpture, metalwork....these are things that I love to see in architecture and design. When I travel, these are what inspire me. Seeing craftsmanship and ingenuity on displace. We see it all around Disneyland, but Tomorrowland always felt devoid of such craftsmanship. Hard, flat, sharp shapes painted flat white. Everything felt plastic and fake. Like a movie set from a Planet of the Apes sequel.
TL 98 was historically a miss, but at the time, I appreciated them going towards a future which felt hand-crafted rather than processed. It reminded me that everything that inspires was built by thought and ingenuity and that scales down to a personal level. I could actually do something like that. Flat amorphous stucco forms just felt cold and devoid of humanity. And a future that is devoid of human fingerprints isn't and never was inspiring to me.